AHA Questions "PATRIOT II"

March 2003

For Immediate Release - February 13, 2003
Contact: Roy Speckhardt (202) 238-9088

(Washington, DC) Attorney General John Ashcroft's staff drafted new "anti-terrorism" legislation to be the sequel of the USA Patriot Act. Mel Lipman, president of the American Humanist Association, responds, "The Domestic Security Enhancement Act of 2003 encroaches on the rights and protections of Americans even more than its predecessor did. At its core this legislation is intended to drastically expand the powers of law enforcement and federal intelligence agencies with apparent disregard for the rights it tramples upon."

Lipman continued, "If the Domestic Security Enhancement Act were to become law we would see our basic freedoms diminished along with key checks and balances on executive branch powers.

As with provisions in the original Patriot Act, this will result in certain individuals being targeted based not on their actions but on their "potential threat," which can be ethnicity, belief, appearance, or other unrelated factors.

Specifically, this legislation would codify existing administrative efforts to secretly arrest citizens and hold them without charges. Government would be immune from judicial oversight of certain surveillance methods. This would expand capital punishment and prevent courts from questioning certain government actions. Perhaps worst of all, it would have a chilling effect on our freedom of association by enabling government to strip citizenship from people who've supported organizations the government deems to have links with terrorism.

During the McCarthy era, Humanist philosopher Corliss Lamont was wrongly accused of being a communist sympathizer and was illegally investigated by the FBI. Fortunately, he was able to use our laws guaranteeing privacy and due process to win judgments and clear his name.

"If this legislation passes, such protections that freed innocent activists in the 1950's will be history. If we continue down this road of sacrificing liberty for false security we will have nothing left to secure. For when freedom goes, more is soon lost, and tyranny usually overwhelms what remains of civil liberties," Lipman stated.

Lipman concluded, "The Domestic Security Enhancement Act is the latest in the Bush Administration's continued efforts to expand executive powers--even at the cost of our rights and liberties. The time to make our voices of dissent heard is now, before government acquires the power to legally stifle us."